“Brand Stand”

The value of brand in cheese is varied from the classic pre-pack to the harder-to-project deli pack, but all compete for recognition and shopper loyalty in a competitive environment. The major cheese brands are in general having a torrid time as so many matters change in the grocery market. That eternal struggle between brand distribution and volume growth has never been more challenging than it is right now

The changing pattern of retail distribution has driven many retailers to pursue their own brands more exclusively, and the rise of the discounters who have always had minimalist brand stocking has added to the pressure of distribution limitation and nil volume growth opportunity.

It’s interesting to see how areas that the major brands ignored for so long, such as deli counter and independents, formerly too small for consideration, are now suddenly so desirable with offers aplenty.

The retailers have long seen brands as a potential cash cow, with budgets to invest and crazy offers to draw the shopper. But that broken model has long since faded, as a year is a lifetime in this trade and the consumer buying pattern is less volume, bought more often, as the savvy shopper avoids waste and buys to their needs.

It’s surely time for a revolution here, something different from that the old tired knock about – to you, to me, brands scramble as shoppers’ lack of loyalty sees them simply buy the best offers. So where is the next big brand idea?

A recent tasting done with a group of knowledgeable Cheddar graders and enthusiasts on over 120 brand lines found the quality of the Cheddar on offer from brands was frankly very average, with little to distinguish them, and in truth some absolutely terrible examples of so called mature, extra mature and vintage types.

That accountants make Cheddar mass-manufactured to a formula is alive and well, and I personally doubt whether there is a real outpouring of enthusiasm sweeping the consumer market driven on a wave of taste enthusiasm, as distinct from price offers and a diet of trendy adverts.

Sitting apart from Cheddar are Continentals and artisan speciality types that have their own challenge in brand recognition.

The main Continental types are in most cases just as mass-manufactured as any UK Cheddar type, but their lesser distribution gives the shopper a misguided belief they are somehow artisan, and it equally well gives the maker the headache of advancing its brand value via the expensive and ineffective conventional media mechanics, so there has been just a few French and Dutch moves into heavyweight brand marketing.

Only the artisan sector has to rely on its brand being extolled by word of mouth, or by its sellers, as the truest endorsement of its brand value. Hard yards at hundreds of country shows, farmers markets, deli counters and a million encounters with consumers to extend their brand awareness.

It’s never easy, never certain, and many enthusiastic moments of shopper enjoyment are lost in time, as access to market distribution or later brand recall are not there to repay all that investment of time and money.

In that war for brand recognition, we in the UK are still very respectful and formal, with only a few names daring to be more than genteel examples of British heritage with local names in profusion.

In my visits to the USA I like the irreverent names adorning their cheese brands – Lamb Chopper, The Lone Grazer, Brutal Blue and others. Not sure that Arse Blaster would be on anyone’s shelves any time soon, though.

In the UK there are few of these, although Lincolnshire Poacher’s Knuckle Duster is always an eye catcher with the public, the makers tell me, and I would believe it.

But it doesn’t need to be a jokey name, it can be a claim to being the best, or truly different. A maker may as well grandstand – if the product is consistently good enough, of course.

A wide number of the brand designs of some artisan cheese look dated and lack impact and quality, and the world has moved on in how it recognises and interprets brand and brand value. It might be comfortable to think that a dated design and layout is somehow the right connect to provenance and the past and to being artisan, but those that truly send that image have often been carefully crafted in good design and branding.

An update, a makeover, a refresh of colour will often make a brand more recognisable to many who forgot it, or better still to those who never saw it before in that maze of products.

After all, the brand is what any artisan or other maker wants the shopper to remember. In a wall of cheese, whether pre-packed or loose, it’s necessary to stand out… so we all need to brand stand a bit.

Latest Reels (Instagram)